Our Resources
Ask Your Agent a Question
Ask Our Lending Partner a Question
Testimonials
"
Cindy is the absolute consummate professional. When we first met she already had materials needed for my town inspection before we could put it on the market. Her comps were spot on and her attention to detail is noteworthy. I highly recommend using her services. She’s is a true master of her craft
"
- Kevin Farrell
"
Tara was absolutely phenomenal! As an attorney who dedicates a large portion of my practice to real estate closings, I know how important the right agent can be. Tara was the right choice. She came to our home to learn about all its features, taking pictures for her own benefit as she moved from room to room and outside in our yard and gardens. She then came back with her home evaluation and marketing strategy which she presented in an honest, professional, and straightforward manner. She allowed us time to think about it, never pressuring us to sign a listing agreement. Even so, she encouraged us to contact her professional stager which we did. The stager was very knowledgeable about home selling trends and helped us showcase the home. Once we signed the listing agreement, Tara was on the go! She did everything she promised in her marketing presentation, and we received an offer at asking price within less than a month! Tara made sure we closed on time, often having to take on tasks that would fall to the buyer’s agent. WHAT MAKES TARA SHINE (aside from her friendly demeanor and smile)? Everything she did which was EXTRA: 1. She came to the house and sat there waiting for the town inspector and then for a plumber when we were out of town and had nobody to help us; 2. She helped us pack and move stuff out of the house when we were out of time (and brought us lunch – she even befriended my mom!); 3. She babysat our dog on the day of closing because we had to travel early that day and his regular sitter wasn’t back until later (she even had our dog, Gus, be an honorary staff member at her office that day). I knew Tara professionally before my closing. Now, I consider her my friend.
"
- Adriana Baudry
"
If you're looking to work with someone knowledgeable in the Housing Market then Tara Lauterbach is the person to work with. Her commitment to find the perfect "place to hang your hat!" is apparent from the moment you meet her. She will work her best to support the best interests of all clients whether moving on up to a bigger home or down sizing when the kids finally leave the nest. I have known Tara for over 20 years and know how much time she has put into her "Craft!"
Cheers
Billy Lockwood
"
- William Lockwood
"
Jim is a wonderful real estate agent. He is attentive and responsive. I would definitely recommend him for all your real estate needs.
"
- Melissa Robertiello
"
Tara lined up ten houses for us to see in one day and was spot on the schedule. Viewing of the houses was quick and professional. She was very professional, organized and full of good advice.
"
- Yevgeniya Solodovnikova
"
Thanks so much Cindy for all your hard work! With your guidance and support we navigated the ever-stressful task of selling our home of 30 years. You responded to all our calls even while on vacation out of the country! The listing price was appropriate, and the process went pretty smoothly.
"
- Janet Hagan
"
If I decide to sell my home, Tara will be my go to Realtor! She has assessed my house for me, and always keeps me informed on current market values and other helpful information that has been very useful. She’s informed, very helpful and you can’t beat her bubbly personality. Thanks Tara!
"
- Sandra Hafner
"
Strong communication, kept us informed every step of the way, before putting our house up for sale and during the process of selling our home. Provided lots of helpful advice to help make the process easier.
"
- Claire Doherty
"
Mindy is the most compassionate, attentive, and reliable realtor I know. She has gone above and beyond her realtor responsibilities to find me the home that suits my needs on short notice. She assisted me throughout the entire process, from property search to finding a cleaning service, a painter, and more. People like Mindy not only help you find your home, but they also assist you in settling into it. I would highly recommend Mindy to anyone buying or selling real estate. I would also like to thank Mindy personally from the bottom of my heart for pouring all of her energy into getting me settled in my new home and making me feel relaxed throughout the entire process.
"
- Melisa Chullum
"
We saw Tara's ad and signed up with her last September. Although we had some familiarity with the area, it took time to learn the local market and Tara was very responsive in showing us houses that might be of interest. It was a tough market for buyers, but she helped us understand what was needed to secure a house that we would enjoying living in. After two unsuccessful bids, we jumped on the third house which we have just moved into and which we like very much. She continues to help us with transitional matters and recommendations on local service providers. We are happy to have worked with her and consider her a friend.
Rich and Pam Berger
"
- Rich and Pam Berger
"
As first time home buyers, we couldn’t imagine going through this experience without Mindy. Her positivity, knowledge & responsiveness was priceless.
The home buying process in 2025 is not for the weak; but Mindy quelled our anxieties and instilled confidence in us.
"
- Ray Black
"
Mindy was great to work with. She made the process easy and had a great command of next steps. Her candid approach and ability to speak of items that I needed to accomplish in order for the best offer/ outcome was priceless. She kept a level head and made herself available for any minute question I had and at times went above and beyond. A true gem to her profession.
"
- Ron Raymond
"
Mindy was simply the best Realtor my wife and I had the pleasure of working with. She looked everywhere to find us the perfect home and answered every question my wife and I had being first time home buyers not understanding the process. She worked around my hectic schedule traveling through Sussex county and Warren county driving sometimes hours to find the right house. Simply put Mindy is an expert in her craft and such a nice person there is no other person I will work with when I am buying a property.
"
- Wayde Beasley
"
Tara is wonderful and very professional.
"
- Donna Stahl
"
Tara has been nothing short of amazing to work with. The care and patience she has comes second to none. She has made my Real Estate experience so smooth and enjoyable. I can not thank you enough Tara L!
"
- Irene cesario
"
Cindy is extremely kind, humble, and a very knowledgeable realtor. She truly is there to help you and she also looks out for your best interests with the best intentions. She is willing to go through basements and crawl spaces to make sure you are getting all the information you need to make the best decision.
Additionally, Cindy never left my side in the 2 1/2 years that I was looking for my first home!! She helped me navigate everything and especially with giving me resources and referrals for every step. Cindy truly is a realtor that is in it to help families and people to find their forever home rather than just making money out of you and not leading you in the best directions and decisions. She truly is an angel that I was bless with to find my forever home with.
"
- Melanie Betancur
"
Cindy is a very organized, detail oriented, and personable individual. I was impressed with her knowledge of the area, and her ability to tell me exactly what to expect from the time the house was listed to the time the sale contract was closed. She was a huge asset all along the way, through the many months I spent cleaning out the estate, to finally selling my family's childhood home. I highly recommend her expertise and experience to prospective sellers and buyers. She really knows her market, and gets everything done efficiently and effectively!
"
- Melissa Wartman
"
One of the things that really set Tara apart was how hands-on and supportive she was throughout the entire process.
Selling our home was no easy task — it was a challenging sale with several unexpected hurdles along the way. But Tara never gave up. She stayed calm, focused, and determined from start to finish, and kept us informed every step of the way.
She didn’t just help us sell our home—she helped us PREPARE to sell it! From offering advice on staging to actually helping us organize the final clean out, she made what could have been an overwhelming task feel manageable.
Her dedication, problem-solving skills, and personal support made all the difference. Thanks to her persistence and expertise, we got the deal done. We are incredibly grateful and would recommend her to anyone looking for a real estate agent who truly goes above and beyond. Tara, thank you again SO MUCH!
"
- Elisa
"
Tara is awesome! She helped me find a home I love and made the whole process so easy. I would definitely recommend using her as your realtor in the future..
"
- Nicole Berger
"
Tara is not only incredibly knowledgeable about the real estate market, but also genuinely friendly and always ready to offer helpful advice. Whether it’s navigating tricky negotiations or providing insightful recommendations, Tara always has the client's best interests in mind.
"
- Mary Grant
"
Jim helped my family and I find a home. He was kind, understanding and went above and beyond; he even helped watch our kids while we signed our paperwork! Would recommend him as your realtor without a second thought.
James "Jim" Sheldon, Realtor
Owner
1 week ago
Thank you Meem, you have wonderful children, very well behaved and fun to be around. Best of luck in your new home! If you need anything please let me know I am not far away.
"
- Meem Hossain
"
Cindy has been a real guardian angel for our home purchase. We were the first time homebuyers and had absolutely no idea about any of the process. Cindy explained every single step with enormous details from the very beginning until the end when we moved into the house and even explained how to take care of a home. Especially in this crazy unpredictable market at the moment, Cindy has been so patient with showing homes and put together many offers for us not to mention answering our endless questions patiently with details including great suggestions on how to bid on the houses. Finally, we got the house that we loved just because Cindy came up with strategy to tweak our offer last minute so that we win the bidding war to get the house. We can’t thank her enough to bear with us for 4 months in this journey. Even her recommended mortgage company , home inspector, attorney everybody was super efficient and our process went so smoothly. Lastly, she made us speechless with the very first housewarming gift we received when we closed on the house😊! Thanks a lot, Cindy for being available for us like a friend day and night and even during your vacation time!
"
- Rafa Tasmin
"
It was a pleasure working with Mindy as our real estate agent in our journey of downsizing once our kids left for college. Mindy was able to find a beautiful, spacious townhouse for us not far from our old neighborhood & friends. She was able to get us in to see some prospective properties the very 1st day on the market, & was always willing to take us back to the properties for repeated looks with our children. In addition, Mindy worked very well with our real estate attorneys. We would highly recommend Mindy as a real estate agent!
"
- Michael Flammer
"
I'm delighted to share our experience with Cindy. Her extensive knowledge and guidance proved invaluable in navigating the process of purchasing our first home. Cindy's dedication was evident as she patiently walked us through each step, offering well-informed advice on offers and negotiations. Her consistent availability, even during evenings and weekends, made us feel well supported. Particularly noteworthy was Cindy's adept communication with the seller's realtor, which played a crucial role in helping us secure our dream home. Her commitment and expertise truly made a difference, and we are extremely pleased with the outcome.
"
- Mark Adams
"
Tara is full of energy and knows our community and the strengths of each area she serves. Her sense of care and compassion makes her an excellent agent! Her incredible work ethic and desire to bring happiness to others are just a few of her amazing qualities!
"
- Deborah Burleigh
"
Cindy is very knowledgeable,professional and honest. She went above and beyond in helping us sell our home. Cindy was always available to answer any questions we had .
I would highly recommend Cindy.
"
- Geralyn McMyne
"
Cindy is extremely knowledgeable and an excellent communicator. She knows the all the processes and procedures in selling a home and goes above and beyond to insure everything that needs to happen does prior to closing. We had a short 30 day close date, with lots of thing to get done, and we closed on time. I would highly recommend her.
"
- Ken Wirth
"
As difficult as the home buying experience is recently with soaring home prices and interest rates, having a great realtor can help ease this burden. Tara was absolutely amazing and always looked for insights and asked inportant questions that sometimes I even forgot to ask. She never made me feel pushed into making an offer and always provided great insight as well as caution when something didn't feel right or things looked off during the home visit! Would highly recommend.
"
- Neophytos Z
"
Cindy was essential in buying and selling homes for me. I would recommend her to anyone. She is knowledgeable, resourceful and personable .
"
- Christopher Shelley
"
Cindy is the consummate professional. She gives great advice about setting up your home for maximum appeal. We have sold two houses with Cindy. Both sold within two days! We would highly recommend selling with Cindy!
"
- Joanne Canizaro
"
Tara was invaluable in our search for a new home. She demonstrated her knowledge of the local market, her negotiating skills, her understanding of the purchase contract and her connection to local professionals for inspections, repairs & upgrades to the property.
She was always easy to communicate with and professional in her responses to our questions & concerns. We were fortunate to work with Tara and recommend her to anyone looking for real estate in her market area.
"
- Jerry Sinkona
"
Tara is awesome! She helped me find a home I love and made the whole process so easy. I would definitely recommend using her as your realtor in the future.
"
- Nicole Berger
"
Tara was absolutely incredible in helping us find our dream home. She not only met all of our requirements but also exceeded our expectations by finding us more than we had hoped for. Her expertise and professionalism were evident throughout the entire process. Tara went above and beyond, even negotiating on our behalf to secure the best possible deal. As a real estate agent with RE/MAX, she truly stands out, and I would highly recommend her to anyone in need of a dedicated and knowledgeable agent.
"
- Eugene Arencibia
"
Tara is very knowledgeable about selling homes. She sold my home for more than was asked or I expected I would get. She provided advice and points of contact for each step of the process.
"
- Albert Rahe
"
Mindy was very pleasant to work with.
Mindy was very pleasant to work with. What I liked most about working with her is she made sure gave us her professional advice and also allowed us to have a say. She cared about how we felt. That’s so important when you're new to navigating this process. Mindy’s communication was impeccable, She was attentive and properly guided us professionally through out this entire home selling process. She also helped is look for new homes. I would absolutely recommend Mindy DiGabriele as your new realtor.
"
- Anonymous
"
It was great working with Tara. Our home buying journey started before the pandemic and we were finally successful in early 2022. Tara stuck with us through thick and thin in a roller coaster/limited inventory market. She gave us valuable advice and was always there for us throughout the whole process. It was a pleasure working with Tara!
"
- Em Viente
"
It’s a great experience to work with Tara. With her years of real estate experience and tremendous insights into the housing market she brings a fresh and innovative perspective to the home buying journey. She always provides updates on market trends, leverages key technologies and ensures her clients have all the available data to make the very important decision of home buying. Tara will be your partner and ensure the success of all your real estate needs.
"
- Joel Altamirano
"
As I am an agent also and have worked along side and opposed to a variety of different agents, I’ve found that there are a few that stand out from the crowd. Tara is one of those stand-outs. Her clients give unanimously stellar reviews, but the difference is that agents do too. Not only does tara alleviate purchase stress for her clients but also for the agents she works with. She goes above professional courtesy and she’s reliable. Tara is the agents’ agent. Call me for any real estate needs. But if you don’t call me, call Tara.
"
- David Cunico
"
Tara is an exceptional woman! Her knowledge of real estate and all its accompanying details is remarkable. She works diligently for her clients with uncompromising energy, listening to their needs. Though I am not currently in the market to buy or sell, I would most assuredly call on Tara when that time comes. I couldn't recommend Tara more.
"
- Linda Reda
"
Cindy Graham was terrific to work with and she had great ideas that we listened to and did all of them. She is very hardworking and experienced and accessible to us when we needed her and met all of our needs. You wont go wrong with , Cindy she is awesome.
"
- Martyw13
"
Tara was outstanding to work with. She was extremely knowledgeable about the vast paperwork which goes into selling a house and knew all of the local codes and procedures one needs to follow. Her positive attitude and energy helped get us to the finish line which at times was tedious. I would enthusiastically recommend her as an agent to anyone buying/selling a property.
"
- Douglas Findlay
"
Jim Sheldon is a wonderful agent working in residential as well as commercial real estate. He knows the local market inside and out. You would be in good hands with Jim as your agent.
James "Jim" Sheldon, Realtor
Owner
2 weeks ago
Thank you Joe! I appreciate your support.
"
- Joseph Nesbihal
"
Although I haven't purchased a home with Tara yet, I have worked professionally with her for many years. Tara is a hard working, honest, trustworthy Realtor who goes out of her way for each client. With her knowledge of the industry and area, Tara would be my first choice for selling my home.
"
- Mike Lang
"
Cindy was always available to guide me through selling our family's home. Her thoroughness and knowledge helped make such a daunting experience easier. I would highly recommend Cindy to anyone looking for a realtor!
"
- Kristina Lagzdins
"
Jim is so easy to work with. He is very knowledgeable and very professional.
"
- Donna Stahl
"
As difficult as the home buying experience is recently with soaring home prices and interest rates, having a great realtor can help ease this Burdon. Tara was absolutely amazing and always looked for insights and asked important questions that sometimes I even forgot to ask. She never made me feel pushed into making an offer and always provided great insight as well as caution when something didn't feel right or things looked off during the home visit! Would highly recommend.
"
- Neophytos Z
"
Mindy is an extraordinary person, knowledgeable, an excellent real estate agent, listen, perform and she is very supportive through the whole process of purchasing a house. Make more easy to understand and take important decisions in this kind of event. She is calm and friendly. I told her to start her own school. My best regards to her and her family. I highly recommended her.
"
- Lourdes Voytac
"
Selling my home was a huge transition, both logistically and emotionally, and I’m so grateful that I had Tara guiding me through every step. She was incredibly professional, knowledgeable about the changing market, and always calm and reassuring — even when things got stressful.
Tara handled every detail with care, from staging and timing the listing to navigating offers and coordinating the final steps leading up to closing. I always felt informed and supported, and she went above and beyond to make sure everything stayed on track.
What stood out most was Tara’s genuine empathy and communication — she truly understood how personal this process was for me and made it feel manageable from start to finish. I can honestly say I couldn’t have asked for a better experience.
I would highly recommend Tara to anyone seeking a realtor who combines expertise, professionalism, and genuine care.
"
- Sylvia Couvertier
"
After 43 years in our home, we decided it was time to downsize and move on. Working with Tara Lauterbach of RE/MAX made the entire process seamless from start to finish. Tara is exceptionally knowledgeable about the market, property valuation, and pricing strategy. Her guidance and expertise resulted in 18 offers on our home, several above the asking price, including multiple cash offers. She was a true professional and partner throughout the transaction—personable, hardworking, responsive, and always advocating for our best interests. Her expert advice in evaluating and negotiating offers helped us achieve an outstanding outcome with a quick and successful sale. Even better, she brought the buyers herself. We could not have been happier with Tara’s performance and highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
"
- Ben Gunderson
"
I have worked with Jim on the rental of a commercial property and his knowledge of that type of property is excellent
"
- Cindy Graham
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. and REMAX Heritage Properties. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX listing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved. This information is being provided for Consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose
